Turned out to be manufactured in the wrong place, with the wrong pellets, just wrong. Ended up being worth about $8. Good thing I only paid $1 for it.
On my third haul I found video games, action figures, and Minecraft.
Nothing really earth shattering profit-wise. The find of the day has to be the Mortal Kombat vs. DC Universe game that I obtained for $5 and ended up selling for $18 + shipping.